Loading Kindness - Spinning Up Mommy Magic

While the Love Loads, Our Spinner Spins. Get Ready to Share, Support, and Bond with Like-minded Moms!

Popular Searches:

What are some effective ways to handle my teen's defiance or noncompliance with rules?

Hi, I am a parent to a 14-year-old teenager who has been pushing boundaries and breaking rules lately. I have been struggling to handle his defiance and noncompliance, and I am not sure what to do. It seems like no matter what consequences I give him, he continues to act out and ignores my rules. I need some advice and effective ways to handle this situation. Any suggestions on how I can deal with my teen's rebellious behavior would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

All Replies


Hi there,

As a father of a 16-year-old son, I can relate to your situation as we also faced similar problems with our teen. One thing that worked for us was giving our son a bit more freedom within our boundaries. We created an environment of mutual respect and understanding that allowed our son to feel trusted and responsible.

Furthermore, we also tried adopting a more lenient approach with our son while still holding him accountable for breaking rules. We started with some small negotiations that both parties can agree upon. This approach gave him some room to express himself and reduced the tension between us, leading him to be more accepting of our rules.

Additionally, we also established ground rules in our house, setting expectations for his behavior and consequences for breaking them. It meant that my son understood that it was essential to follow the rules to earn greater trust and freedom. If he chose not to adhere to these ground rules, he knew that there would be consequences.

Finally, we constantly reminded him of our expectations and reinforced them with positive affirmations when he complied. This positive reinforcement encouraged him to act in the desired way, resulting in fewer conflicts in our household.

In conclusion, I believe that it's essential to give your teenager some space while still remaining firm with your family rules. Create a mutual understanding and build a trusted relationship through open communication, lenient negotiations, and positive reinforcement.


Hi there, as a parent to a 17-year-old teen who went through a similar phase, I can relate to your situation. I found that communication was key in dealing with my teen's defiance. Instead of just enforcing rules and consequences, I started having more open conversations with him about why those rules were in place and how his actions were affecting our family.

I also learned to pick my battles wisely and prioritize the important rules for safety and well-being. It's easy to get caught up in small things and create unnecessary power struggles. By choosing my battles, it gave my teen a sense of control and allowed us to focus on the rules that really mattered.

Another approach that worked for me was positive reinforcement. Instead of only punishing my teen for bad behavior, I would also praise and reward him for good behavior. This helped to create a more positive atmosphere and encouraged him to continue following the rules.

Overall, every situation is unique and what works for one family may not work for another, but I hope these ideas can be helpful in your situation. Good luck and stay positive, it will get better!


Hello everyone,

As a parent to two teenagers, I can relate to the challenges of dealing with defiance and noncompliance with rules. In my experience, one strategy that has worked for me is to teach my teens how their actions have consequences beyond their individual behavior.

I found that explaining to them how their choices and behavior can affect not only their lives but also the lives of those around them was an effective way to motivate them to act more responsibly. I used real-life examples of the consequences of bad behavior, both positive and negative, to create a sense of understanding and help them understand the implications of their actions.

Another strategy that has worked for us is to provide them with more autonomy when it comes to decision-making, within reason. We discussed the consequences of their choices, and I trust them more, which has led to fewer arguments and less defiance.

Also, I found it helpful to harness technology to reduce conflict. As teens are fond of using technology, we set up a family agreement that outlines how we use our devices at home. This way, they understand that the same rules apply to all members of the family and there's no bias on my part.

Lastly, I think it’s important to praise and recognize positive body language when our teen begins to cooperate or change their behavior. It communicates to them that their efforts have not gone unnoticed, and an increase in your positivity towards them is a powerful motivator.

In conclusion, understanding the cause of your teen's defiance, teaching them to recognize the consequences of their decisions, and rewarding positive behavior and body language can be helpful in reducing their defiance and promoting compliance with household rules.


Hi everyone,

As a parent to a 16-year-old daughter who tends to be defiant, I've discovered that effective communication and collaboration are essential in handling noncompliance with rules. Instead of just laying down the law, I've found that talking with my daughter about her feelings and the reasons behind her defiance helped to build a healthier parent-child relationship.

One of the things that worked for us was to sit down together and have a conversation about what our family's rules really meant to each of us. My daughter expressed her point of view and what she thought would be a fair bargaining point. In the end, we were able to come up with some compromises that worked for both of us.

Another strategy that worked was helping my daughter to own her mistakes and take responsibility for her behavior. We talked with her about the consequences of her actions, and made sure that she understood that her choices had consequences. This approach taught her self-accountability and how to take responsibility for the things that she had done wrong.

Lastly, I found that reinforcing respectful behavior led to a more cooperative attitude toward compliance with rules. Complimenting and praising respectful behavior went a long way in reinforcing positive behavior and fostering a more positive parent-teen relationship.

In conclusion, understanding and taking the time to talk with your teenager, and working on solutions collaboratively can help establish mutual respect and understanding, leading to a healthier parent-child relationship. It takes time, patience, and consistency, but it's worth it.


Hello everyone,

As a parent to a 15-year-old son, I can relate to the struggle of handling defiance and noncompliance. One strategy that has been effective for me is to work collaboratively with my son to establish clear expectations, boundaries, and consequences.

We began by exploring the root cause of his rebellious behavior, and I discovered that he felt like he didn't have a voice or any control over his life. I asked him to propose some ideas of how he could take ownership within the established boundaries, and we worked together to come up with a mutually agreed-on set of rules.

Additionally, instead of just imposing punishments, I used the opportunity of negative behavior to talk with him about his emotions and why he acted out. It allowed him to understand where his behavior came from, helping him to express more comfortably rather than to suppress his emotions through acting out.

Another thing that worked for us was to create a supportive environment built on trust and mutual respect. When you have an open, honest, and supportive relationship with your teen, it becomes easier to address defiance and noncompliance. This approach helps to build their confidence so that they are more willing to cooperate with you.

In conclusion, working collaboratively with your teen, using open communication, and building a supportive environment are practical strategies that can help manage your teenager's defiance and noncompliance with household rules. With time, patience, and consistency, you can establish a healthy and respectful relationship with them.


Hello there,

I am a mother of a 15-year-old daughter who tends to be quite defiant at times. I found that getting to the root of her defiance was helpful in tackling her noncompliance with rules. Usually, when her behavior started to change, I would ask her to talk about what’s going on in her life that might be causing her to act out.

Through discussions, I found out that my daughter was going through a lot and needed my help. We created some trust between us, that allowed her to thank me for taking her mental health seriously. I used this opportunity to seek professional help, and advised her to join some online support groups where she can interact with her peers and talk to a therapist regularly.

In addition to that, we created a reward system for her good behaviors. For every time she complies with the family rules, especially those that affect her safety, like not using her phone while driving, we rewarded her. This made her understand that acting out will not only lead to punishments but also not allow her to receive the rewards.

Finally, as parents, we must ensure that our messages align with our actions. If I expect my daughter to be truthful, then I need to demonstrate honesty in our interactions. This goes also for respect, fairness, and kindness on both sides.

I hope my experience helps someone out there having a similar difficulty.



I am a mother to two teenage boys, and I understand how it feels when your teen is defiant or not complying with rules. In my experience, one of the most effective ways to handle this is by listening and showing empathy. It can be challenging to balance being a parent and a listener, especially with teenagers with their personal struggles.

However, by listening and empathizing with your teen, it can help build a rapport and trust. This can be useful in understanding your teen's worldview and providing a solution that is effective. When we show our teens that we understand their struggles, it can help them feel heard and validated, and lead to a more cooperative attitude towards rule-following.

Additionally, when a teen is acting out, they may be inadvertently sending a message that they are dealing with stress or something challenging. As parents, it is essential to check in regularly and ask open-ended questions to understand their emotions, instead of focusing on their behavior. This way, you can pinpoint what the root cause of their defiance is.

Lastly, it's vital to create an environment that encourages positive behavior. Instead of focusing on punishment, I found that rewarding positive behaviors can create incentives for your teen to comply with the rules. This approach can also help build a positive relationship between you both.

In conclusion, by listening, empathizing, and encouraging positive behavior, it can help you better handle your teen's defiance or noncompliance with rules, leading to a more harmonious relationship with your teen.


Greetings everyone,

As a parent to a 13-year-old daughter who tends to be defiant, I have experienced the difficulties of handling this behavior in a constructive way. One of the things that worked for me and my daughter was establishing clear rules and consequences for breaking them.

We sat down together and discussed the rules and the consequences, and my daughter had the opportunity to ask questions or provide any suggestions that would make her feel more comfortable. This way, she was an active participant in the rule-setting process, and it did not feel like the rules were being imposed on her.

It's also essential to be consistent with the consequences when she defies or doesn’t comply with the rules. By following through on the consequences, your teen will understand that there's no wiggle room or exceptions, and they will be accountable for their actions.

Additionally, keeping a calm and collected demeanor is vital when your teen is being defiant. As parents, we need to lead by example when they're acting out. In this way, you are not fueling their defiance by reacting emotionally.

Finally, we must make sure that we provide our teens with appropriate guidance, support, and supervision while also promoting their independence. Positive reinforcement of good behavior through a sense of recognition and compliments can go a long way in supporting your teenager's autonomy and identifying what you expect from them.

Always remember, being a parent is hard, but by adopting some of these strategies, we can create an environment of mutual respect and understanding with our teens that will be helpful in the long run.

New to Kind Mommy Community?

Join the community