Loading Kindness - Spinning Up Mommy Magic

While the Love Loads, Our Spinner Spins. Get Ready to Share, Support, and Bond with Like-minded Moms!

Popular Searches:

What are some alternatives to time-outs or other traditional forms of discipline?

Hi everyone,

I am a parent of a 4-year-old child and I am currently struggling with disciplining my child without using the traditional form of discipline such as time-outs, spanking or yelling. I feel that these forms of discipline do not seem to work for my child and I want to explore alternatives that are more effective and positive.

I want to create a discipline strategy that helps my child to understand the consequences of his actions and make better choices without feeling punished or shamed. I also want to build a strong and healthy relationship with my child that is based on trust and mutual respect.

So, if you have any suggestions for alternative forms of discipline that have worked for you or for someone you know, please share them with me. I am open to any ideas or strategies that can help me become a better parent and raise a happy and well-adjusted child.

Thank you in advance for your help!

All Replies


Hi there,

I can relate to your struggles with traditional forms of discipline. Something that worked for me as a parent was implementing natural consequences.

For example, if my child refused to wear a jacket when it was cold outside, instead of forcing him to wear it or punishing him, I would let him experience the natural consequence of feeling cold. Similarly, if he didn't finish his homework, I would let him face the natural consequence of not being able to participate in his favorite after-school activities.

Another technique that has worked for me is validating my child's emotions. When my child is upset or angry, I try my best to understand and validate her feelings, even if I may not agree with her behavior. This helps her feel heard and understood, which in turn calms her down and helps her regulate her behavior.

I hope these ideas help you establish a positive relationship with your child and encourage good behavior in a non-punitive way.

Best of luck!


Hi there,

I understand your challenge as a parent to discipline your child without using traditional forms of discipline. In such cases, I have found that using empathy as a tool while also setting clear boundaries can be effective.

Empathy helps children feel understood and heard. When a child is acting out, I try to understand the reasons behind the behavior instead of punishing or ignoring them. By acknowledging their feelings, I can de-escalate the situation and talk through different strategies to deal with it.

Setting clear boundaries is another important step. When children know what is expected of them, it can help them understand what is acceptable and what is not. I try to communicate my expectations in a calm and clear way: "We don't hit our friends. If you feel angry, you can say that you don't like what they are doing."

Lastly, I have found that reinforcing positive behavior is crucial. When a child acts in a desirable way, I praise them and let them know that I appreciate their behavior. This can help to reinforce the positive behavior and make it more likely for it to be repeated in the future.

I hope these suggestions help you in developing an approach to discipline that works for you and your child.

Best of luck!


Hi there,

I completely understand your frustration with traditional forms of discipline. I went through the same thing with my own child when he was younger. What worked for me was implementing positive reinforcement, which is a disciplinary technique focused on rewarding desirable behavior instead of punishing bad behavior.

For example, my child loved playing video games, so I set a specific goal for him to achieve, such as reading for 30 minutes or cleaning up his toys, and promised him a certain amount of game time as a reward once he accomplished his task. This way, he was motivated to complete his task and felt proud of himself when he accomplished it.

Another technique that worked well for us was redirecting. Instead of scolding or punishing my child for undesirable behavior such as throwing a tantrum or hitting his sister, I would calmly acknowledge his feelings and then redirect his attention to something more positive such as reading a book, playing with a toy or going for a walk.

I hope these suggestions help you and your child build a more positive and healthy parent-child relationship. Remember, every child is different, so it may take some trial and error to find what works best for your family.

Best of luck!


Hi everyone,

I understand the struggle of disciplining children without using traditional methods. My personal experience has shown that giving children a voice by involving them in decision-making processes can help them feel respected and empowered.

For instance, I involve my child in setting expectations and consequences. We discuss what is acceptable behavior and what isn't and decide together on consequences for misbehavior. This helps my child feel like an active participant in the disciplinary process and understand the reasons behind the consequences.

Another method that I found useful is giving children choices. Instead of telling them what to do, I offer them a choice between two different options that are both acceptable for me. This way, they feel empowered to make a decision, and it gives them a sense of autonomy and control.

Lastly, I believe in the benefits of open communication. Talking with my child and really listening to her point of view has helped me to better understand her motives and reasons behind her behavior. This has helped me to provide a more informed and appropriate response.

I hope these strategies help you create a more positive and effective approach to discipline.

Best of luck!


Hello there,

I can understand your concern about using traditional discipline methods with your child. I have also faced similar problems with my child and found that positive reinforcement is a great way to encourage good behavior.

For instance, whenever my child listens to me and does something well, I would reward her with praise or small treats like a favorite snack or an extra story time before bed. This helps my child feel good about herself, build positive self-esteem, and encourages her to repeat the desirable behavior in the future.

Another parenting strategy that I found helpful is a "time-in" rather than a time-out. Instead of isolating or punishing my child, I would stay close to her, gently reconnect, and talk through our emotions together. This helps to build a stronger relationship and reduce the likelihood of negative behavior in the future.

I hope that these techniques help you and your child, but keep in mind that every child is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. Stay patient, try different methods, and always remember to show love and support to your child.

Best of luck!


Hi there,

I empathize with your feelings about using traditional forms of discipline. As a parent myself, I have also found it to be less effective with my child. Instead, I have found that using logical consequences works better.

Logical consequences help children to understand the connection between their behavior and the outcome. For instance, if my child refuses to put away her toys, instead of punishing her, I might say something like, "If you don't clean up your toys, we won't be able to play with them later." This way, I am allowing her to experience the natural result of her actions without shaming or punishing her.

Another method that I found useful is the "take a break" strategy. It is similar to a time-out but instead of isolating the child, it provides an opportunity to calm down and think about their behavior. When my child becomes upset or agitated, I encourage her to take a break by sitting in a quiet space to reflect on her behavior and try to find a solution. This way, she can learn to regulate her own emotions and behavior.

I hope these ideas can help you explore different forms of discipline and create a positive environment for both you and your child.

Best of luck!


Hi there,

I can completely understand your concern about traditional forms of discipline and the need for an alternative approach. In my experience, focusing on positive tracking can be an effective way to encourage positive behavior.

This method involves tracking desirable behavior and rewarding the child for it. For instance, we may have a chart that tracks how many days they brush their teeth or clean their room without being reminded. If they reach a certain milestone, we reward them with something special they enjoy, like their favorite meal or a trip to the park.

Another technique that may be helpful is modeling appropriate behavior. I try to model appropriate behavior myself, and when they make a mistake, I model how to correct it. For example, if my child throws a tantrum, I model calm breathing or talk with them about different strategies they could use next time.

In addition, I have found that taking a break when things get overwhelming is helpful for both parents and children. I sometimes take a quick break when my child tantrums or acts out, gather myself, then come back to the situation more calm and clear-headed. This has helped me to respond in a more productive manner and reduced the potential for further negative behavior.

I hope these suggestions help in developing an effective way to discipline your child.

Best of luck!



As a parent, I completely understand the need for alternatives to traditional forms of discipline. One technique that has worked well for me is giving my child the opportunity to make reparations when they make poor choices.

For example, if my child breaks a toy of his sibling's, I ask him to come up with a plan to make it right. This may involve apologizing, helping to clean up or even earning money to replace the broken toy. This puts the responsibility on my child to understand the consequences of their actions and teaches them to approach problem-solving in a mature and constructive way.

Another effective strategy is focusing on empathy and connection. When my child is upset or misbehaving, I try to put myself in his shoes and understand what he is feeling. By showing empathy and validating his emotions, I can often calm him down and shift his attitudes towards positive behavior.

Lastly, I recommend parents to aim for a healthy balance of discipline and trust. By building a strong foundation of trust with your child, they become more willing to listen and less likely to act out. With trust in place, discipline can feel less like punishment and more like an opportunity for growth and learning.

I hope these ideas help! Best of luck on your parenting journey.

New to Kind Mommy Community?

Join the community