Loading Kindness - Spinning Up Mommy Magic

While the Love Loads, Our Spinner Spins. Get Ready to Share, Support, and Bond with Like-minded Moms!

Popular Searches:
545
Q:

How does a Co-Sleeper compare to a pack and play for use during travel or temporary sleeping arrangements?

Hey everyone,

I'm a first-time mom, and my husband and I are about to take our first vacation with our four-month-old daughter. We're trying to figure out what sleeping arrangements will work best for us during our trip.

We're considering either a co-sleeper or a pack and play for our daughter to sleep in. We have a co-sleeper at home that we love, but we're not sure if it's the best option for traveling. On the other hand, a pack and play seems like a practical choice, but we've never used one before, and we're not sure if it will be comfortable enough for our daughter.

Can anyone who has experience with both a co-sleeper and a pack and play provide some insight into how they compare for use during travel or temporary sleeping arrangements? We're especially interested in hearing about any pros and cons that we should consider, as well as any tips for making either option work well for our daughter. Thank you in advance for your help!

All Replies

jsmitham

Hi there,

I'm a dad-of-two, and we've used both a co-sleeper and a pack and play during travel and temporary sleeping arrangements. In my experience, there are pros and cons to both options.

One significant advantage of the co-sleeper is that it's more comfortable for the parent. Since the baby is sleeping right next to you, it's easier to check on them, change their diaper, or soothe them back to sleep if necessary. Also, you don't have to get up out of bed every time the baby needs you, which can be helpful for a tired parent. However, if you're a restless sleeper or move around a lot, this can also be a potential danger to the baby.

On the other hand, a pack and play can offer a safe, separate sleeping space for the baby. It's also easier to move around, store, and transport, making it a practical choice for travel. However, it can be more challenging to tend to the baby at night, especially if they're fussy or need to be fed often.

In terms of comfort, we found that both the co-sleeper and pack and play were suitable for our children, as long as we brought along familiar bedding for them.

Overall, both the co-sleeper and pack and play have their advantages and disadvantages. It really depends on the individual needs and preferences of the family. While the co-sleeper can provide comfort and convenience, the pack and play can offer a safe and separate sleeping space, which can be important if you're traveling or sharing a room with others.

nadams

Hi there,

I've used both a co-sleeper and a pack and play for my children during travel and temporary sleeping arrangements. Personally, I found that the pack and play was a better choice for us.

One advantage of the pack and play is that it's more versatile. It can double as a playpen during the day and a sleeping space at night. It's also much easier to transport since it can be folded up and stored in a carrying bag. On the other hand, the co-sleeper is bulkier, and it can be tricky to pack and transport.

Another issue we experienced with the co-sleeper was that it was difficult to find a safe and close place to set it up while traveling. Some hotels or homes we stayed in did not have enough space for the co-sleeper to be positioned safely. In contrast, a pack and play can simply be put in the corner of a room or any suitable space.

In terms of comfort, I didn't notice a significant difference between the two options. As long as we brought along familiar bedding and sleepwear, our children seemed to sleep well in either a co-sleeper or a pack and play.

Overall, while I do love our co-sleeper at home, for travel and temporary sleeping arrangements, I would recommend a pack and play for its convenience, versatility, and ease of transport.

juvenal.pacocha

Hi everyone,

As a parent of three, we've traveled quite a bit with our children, and typically bring both a co-sleeper and pack and play with us. In my experience, both options have their benefits depending on what you are looking for.

One major advantage of the co-sleeper is that it allows you to maintain your child's sleeping routine and comfort, especially if your child is used to sleeping in a co-sleeping environment. It can also help with breastfeeding, and you don't have to worry about getting up in the middle of the night to attend to the baby.

However, packing up the co-sleeper and transporting it can be a logistical challenge, especially if you're also packing up other baby gear. It can also be bulky and heavy, which can be a problem if you're flying and have to navigate through busy airports.

On the other hand, pack and plays are generally easier to transport and set up in a new environment. They are versatile and can be used as playpens or sleep spaces, and are specifically designed with travel in mind. They also don't take up too much space, which can be handy if you're in a smaller hotel room.

However, pack and plays can take some getting used to, especially if your child is used to sleeping in a co-sleeper environment. It can also be challenging to get your child to sleep in a new environment, which can lead to some sleepless nights.

Overall, both co-sleepers and pack and plays have their advantages and disadvantages for traveling. It really depends on your family's specific needs, preferences, and your travel style.

bradtke.jamarcus

Hello,

As a mom of two, we've used both a co-sleeper and pack and play during our travels. In my experience, pack and plays are more versatile for various temporary sleeping arrangements, especially if you have more than one child traveling with you.

When traveling with two children, each child can have their own pack and play, which provides enough sleeping space for the whole family. Pack and plays are designed to be adaptable, making them ideal for different sleeping arrangements in different environments. Pack and plays are also easy to set up, compact, and portable, making them easy to carry around to your destination.

However, I also found that co-sleepers have a particular advantage in maintaining the sleeping routine of newborns. The co-sleeper is just like a baby’s bed at home, so they quickly adapt to sleeping in them. This makes it easier for the whole family to get the rest they need, especially in situations where long flights or road trips are involved.

In terms of comfort, both pack and plays and co-sleepers can be comfortable for babies, as long as you bring along your baby's familiar bedding. However, pack and plays can be somewhat less comfortable than co-sleepers, especially for parents who co-sleep with their children at home.

Overall, both co-sleepers and pack and plays have their advantages and disadvantages while traveling. Depending on your preferences and needs, one of them may be more suitable than the other.

melisa67

Hey there,

I'm a mom of two, and we've used both a co-sleeper and a pack and play during travel and temporary sleeping arrangements. Personally, I prefer the co-sleeper over the pack and play.

One significant advantage of the co-sleeper over the pack and play is that it allowed us to maintain our baby's sleeping routine as closely as possible. Our baby was used to sleeping right beside us at home, so using the co-sleeper while traveling helped maintain that sense of familiarity and comfort. The pack and play, on the other hand, can feel more like a foreign environment, as it doesn't allow for the same closeness as the co-sleeper.

Another advantage of the co-sleeper is its smaller size. We found it easier to fit the co-sleeper in tight spaces or smaller hotel rooms. Traveling with a pack and play can often feel like hauling around extra baggage.

The comfort level of both the co-sleeper and pack and play was generally not an issue for us. However, I did find that the co-sleeper was easier to clean, and the sheets were easier to wash compared to the pack and play sheets, which tend to be bulkier and more challenging to clean.

Overall, while a pack and play can be a practical choice for some families, if you're used to co-sleeping, the co-sleeper may be the better choice to maintain your baby's routine while traveling.

legros.shawn

Hello there,

As the mother of a 6-month-old, we recently took our first trip with her and brought a pack and play with us. One advantage I noticed with the pack and play is that it's great for daytime naps. When you're in a hotel or someone else's home, it can be hard to find a safe and comfortable space for your baby to nap during the day. The pack and play, however, can be set up in any room, which is great when your little one needs to take a midday snooze.

Another benefit of the pack and play is that it's relatively easy to clean. When traveling, there can be spills, accidents, and messes, and the pack and play is easy to wipe down or even throw the sheets in the laundry. In contrast, I found that the co-sleeper requires a bit more maintenance and can be more difficult to clean while on the go.

One disadvantage of the pack and play is that it can be challenging to fit into smaller hotel rooms or other accommodations. It can also be more challenging to customize to fit your child's needs. In contrast, a co-sleeper can be more customized to your child with pillows, blankets, and other cozy items.

Overall, both the pack and play and co-sleeper have their benefits and drawbacks when it comes to temporary sleeping arrangements during travel. Ultimately, the decision depends on your family's preferences and needs.

New to Kind Mommy Community?

Join the community