Loading Kindness - Spinning Up Mommy Magic

While the Love Loads, Our Spinner Spins. Get Ready to Share, Support, and Bond with Like-minded Moms!

Popular Searches:

How can I involve my child in the discipline process in a way that is respectful and effective?

Hi everyone,

I'm a parent to a boisterous 4-year-old who is constantly pushing boundaries and testing limits. I'm looking for advice on how to involve my child in the discipline process in a way that is respectful and effective.

I really want my child to understand why certain behaviors are wrong and learn to make better choices in the future. However, I don't want to resort to punishment or yelling, as I believe this will only create more resentment and make my child less likely to listen to me in the future.

So, I'm hoping to get some tips from other parents or child development experts on how to approach discipline in a way that engages my child and helps them learn while still feeling respected and loved. Any advice or stories of what has worked for you would be greatly appreciated!

Thank you in advance.

All Replies


Hello everyone,

I have a 7-year-old child and what works for us regarding discipline is by setting boundaries and consequences. For us, everything boils down to natural consequences, where my child learns from their misbehavior and mistakes.

For instance, if my child refuses to do homework, I would give them a warning and explain the consequences - such as the possibility of getting lower grades, that could result in my child losing privileges such as screen time or playtime. If they still do not fulfill their homework, then I would stick to the consequences that were laid out.

It is crucial to be consistent in this approach, and I always ensure that I am not acting out of anger or frustration but out of concern and guidance. Children learn from their mistakes, and natural consequences help teach them about the cause-and-effect relationship of their actions.

While it might be tough to stick to this approach sometimes, I have found that it has helped my child take responsibility for their actions and learn from their misbehavior. I hope this helps and good luck!


Hi there,

As a parent to a 6-year-old, I completely understand your struggle with enforcing discipline in a respectful way. What has worked for me and my child is creating a routine and setting expectations beforehand.

For example, before entering a store or a restaurant, I take a few minutes to explain to my child what my expectations are – such as walking instead of running, using a quiet voice instead of yelling, etc. I encourage my child to ask questions, so they understand what is expected of them.

If there is a misbehavior, I calmly remind my child of the expectations and redirect them towards a positive behavior. This way, my child knows what they did wrong and why they need to do better in the future, without feeling attacked or shamed.

Overall, I have found that setting clear expectations and sticking to them consistently can create a positive environment for teaching children about appropriate behavior. I hope this helps and good luck with your parenting journey!


Hi there!

I can definitely relate to your situation. My 3-year-old is also very active and constantly testing boundaries. I have found that involving my child in the discipline process can really help them understand the reasons behind why certain behaviors are not acceptable.

One approach that has worked for me is to sit down with my child after a misbehavior and have a conversation about what happened. I ask them why they did what they did, and then explain why their behavior was not okay. I then ask for their input on what they think they can do differently in the future.

This approach not only helps my child feel heard and respected, but it also opens up a dialogue where we can work together to find solutions for better behavior. I also try to focus on positive reinforcement, praising my child for good behavior and acknowledging their efforts to improve.

Of course, this approach takes patience and time, but in my experience, it has been much more effective in the long run than simply resorting to punishment or yelling. I hope this helps, and feel free to ask any follow-up questions!


Hi there,

As a parent of a 10-year-old, I have found that involving my child in the discipline process has been instrumental in helping them take ownership of their behavior.

One technique that has worked well for us is the "time-out." But, instead of just sending my child to sit in a corner, I ask my child to take a break to calm down and think about what happened. During this time, my child can read a book, do a puzzle, or engage in any other quiet activity that they like.

Once my child is calm, we sit down and talk about what happened and how their behavior affected others. I ask for their perspective and feelings about the situation, and we discuss alternative ways they can handle the situation in the future.

This approach has helped my child take responsibility for their behavior and think critically about the impact of their actions. It also helps my child feel respected and understood, which fosters a positive relationship and open communication with them.

Overall, involving my child in the discipline process has been an excellent way to help them make responsible choices and develop good character. I hope this helps and good luck with your parenting journey!

New to Kind Mommy Community?

Join the community